6-Month, Flavor Sampler Mighty Bagel Subscription Box

Regular price $149.00 Save $-149.00

Pay ahead and save, plus get Free Shipping! Our prepaid 6-month Flavor Sampler Mighty Bagel Box subscription is the perfect holiday gift — or a thoughtful send for someone in need of a virtual hug. Don't forget to leave a note at checkout.

Our Mighty Bagel Box is the best way to sample all of our fresh-milled bagel flavors — or it’s the perfect gift for the person who has everything. (Everything but our EVERYTHING bagel... get it?) Sample away. It's a delicious, wholesome introduction to the fresh-milled difference!

This ships 1 time per month for 6 consecutive months. 


  • 2 Packs (8ct) Whole Wheat Plain Bagels
  • 1 Pack (4ct) Whole Wheat Everything Bagels
  • 1 Pack (4ct) Whole Wheat Cinnamon Raisin Bagels


Orders placed on Thursday after 1 pm and on the weekend are shipped on Monday.


Please note that our bagels maintain their quality when frozen. We recommend that you freeze immediately if you can’t eat our bagels within 5 days of receipt.

    How it Works

    Enjoy FREE SHIPPING and easy access to nutritious and delicious Fresh-Milled foods.

    Subscribe and Save

    Choose the bagel bundle that meets your needs, then subscribe for free shipping and ultimate convenience.

    Shipped FREE and FRESH

    From our mill to your doorstep. Our delicious fresh-milled bagels are delivered automatically based on the frequency you chose.

    Adjust Anytime

    You can cancel, pause, or modify your subscription at any time. Nothing hidden. It’s that simple.

    Join the Fresh-Milling Community!

    When you subscribe, you’re joining a community that believes that ethically farmed, organic grains & fresh-milling can improve our health, the soil and the environment.

    We doing things differently.

    Why Fresh-Milling Matters

    Try Fresh-Milled

    Shipping Geography

    Because we’re committed to the freshest product arriving at your door, we are only shipping to the following region and states:

    Massachusetts, Maine, Vermont, New Hampshire, Connecticut, Rhode Island, Indiana, Kentucky, Maryland, New Jersey, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, Virginia, Washington D.C., West Virginia, Florida, Georgia, Alabama, Tennessee, Missouri, Illinois, Iowa, Kansas, Michigan, Minnesota, Wisconsin, Oklahoma, Texas.

    Hear From Our Customers